My Secure Advantage® vs SmartDollar

Compare and evaluate My Secure Advantage® vs SmartDollar based on data from reviews, publicly available sources, and thousands of searches run on Shortlister’s app sign up for a free account.

My Secure Advantage® offers Financial Coaching, Financial Education, Cash Flow & Budgeting to companies with 32,000,000 employees. SmartDollar offers Financial Education, Cash Flow & Budgeting, Financial Coaching to companies with 3,600,000 employees.

The information in these side-by-side comparisons can be used to help your company make the best choice for its employees.

SmartDollar

4.5 (165)

Product Description

My Secure Advantage®

MSA (My Secure Advantage) is passionately committed to eradicating financial stress in the workplace. For 40 years, we’ve helped over... Show More

SmartDollar

SmartDollar is an employer-sponsored financial wellness benefit built on Ramsey Solutions' 7 Baby Steps framework. It helps employees build confidence... Show More

Min. Group Size

My Secure Advantage®

100 eligible

SmartDollar

5 eligible

Lives Serviced

My Secure Advantage®

32,000,000

SmartDollar

5,000,000

Product Specific Features

My Secure Advantage®

✓

Financial health assessment

✓

One-on-one financial coaching - In-person

✓

Goal setting and tracking

✓

One-on-one financial coaching - virtual

Not offered

Mentor/Coach matching

✓

On-site group workshops

✓

Budget tool

✓

Cashflow tool

✓

Contest and reward management

✓

Benefits management

✓

Accredited financial coaches

✓

Debt management counseling

✓

Courses administration

SmartDollar

✓

Financial health assessment

✓

One-on-one financial coaching - In-person

✓

Goal setting and tracking

✓

One-on-one financial coaching - virtual

✓

Mentor/Coach matching

✓

On-site group workshops

✓

Budget tool

✓

Cashflow tool

✓

Contest and reward management

Not offered

Benefits management

✓

Accredited financial coaches

✓

Debt management counseling

✓

Courses administration

Features

My Secure Advantage®

✓

Global Capabilities

✓

iOS Native Application

✓

Android Native Application

✓

Responsive Design

✓

GDPR Compliant

✓

SSAE 18 / SOC Audit(s) Performed

✓

3rd Party Integrations

SmartDollar

✓

iOS Native Application

✓

Android Native Application

✓

Responsive Design

✓

SSAE 18 / SOC Audit(s) Performed

✓

3rd Party Integrations

Official Resources

My Secure Advantage®

SmartDollar

Media

My Secure Advantage®

SmartDollar

About

My Secure Advantage®

My Secure Advantage's (MSA) holistic 3-pillar solution empowers members to take control of their finances, build lasting skills, and achieve... Show More

SmartDollar

SmartDollar serves over 5 million employees nationwide, across organizations from fast-growing companies to large enterprises, spanning healthcare, manufacturing, retail, construction,... Show More

Founded

My Secure Advantage®

1986

SmartDollar

1991

Location

My Secure Advantage®

Roseville, CA

SmartDollar

Franklin, TN

Employees

My Secure Advantage®

100

SmartDollar

1,000

Funding Summary

My Secure Advantage®

None

SmartDollar

None

Website

Reviews

My Secure Advantage®

4.0 (6)

SmartDollar

4.5 (165)

Star Featured Review

Erin Wackerhagen

September 3, 2026
Smart Dollar has been life-changing for several of our employees. It has allowed them to take control of their finances... More
Star Featured Review

Blythe Pettibone-Thompson

September 3, 2026
SmartDollar is an excellent way to provide a sound financial resource to your organization or company. It results in better... More
Show All Reviews

×
?

Need Help Choosing?

Our specialists can help prioritize the criteria that matters most and narrow the field.
Setup a Free Consult

×