SmartDollar vs My Secure Advantage®

Compare and evaluate SmartDollar vs My Secure Advantage® based on data from reviews, publicly available sources, and thousands of searches run on Shortlister’s app sign up for a free account.

SmartDollar offers Financial Education, Cash Flow & Budgeting, Financial Coaching to companies with 3,600,000 employees. My Secure Advantage® offers Financial Coaching, Financial Education, Cash Flow & Budgeting to companies with 32,000,000 employees.

The information in these side-by-side comparisons can be used to help your company make the best choice for its employees.

Product Description

SmartDollar

We believe that everyone can benefit from financial wellness including those with the highest risk or financial need. We understand... Show More

My Secure Advantage®

MSA (My Secure Advantage) is passionately committed to eradicating financial stress in the workplace. For 40 years, we’ve helped over... Show More

Min. Group Size

SmartDollar

2 eligible

My Secure Advantage®

100 eligible

Lives Serviced

SmartDollar

4,294,967,295

My Secure Advantage®

32,000,000

Product Specific Features

SmartDollar

✓

Financial health assessment

✓

Budget tool

✓

Cashflow tool

✓

Contest and reward management

Not offered

Benefits management

✓

Accredited financial coaches

✓

Debt management counseling

✓

Education courses administration

My Secure Advantage®

✓

Financial health assessment

✓

Budget tool

✓

Cashflow tool

✓

Contest and reward management

✓

Benefits management

✓

Accredited financial coaches

✓

Debt management counseling

✓

Education courses administration

Features

SmartDollar

✓

iOS Native Application

✓

Android Native Application

✓

Responsive Design

✓

SSAE 18 / SOC Audit(s) Performed

✓

3rd Party Integrations

My Secure Advantage®

✓

Global Capabilities

Not offered

iOS Native Application

Not offered

Android Native Application

✓

Responsive Design

✓

GDPR Compliant

✓

SSAE 18 / SOC Audit(s) Performed

✓

3rd Party Integrations

Official Resources

SmartDollar

My Secure Advantage®

Media

SmartDollar

My Secure Advantage®

About

SmartDollar

Trusted by thousands of benefits teams and HR leaders across industries, SmartDollar empowers workforces to improve financial behaviors while increasing... Show More

My Secure Advantage®

My Secure Advantage's (MSA) holistic 3-pillar solution empowers members to take control of their finances, build lasting skills, and achieve... Show More

Founded

SmartDollar

1991

My Secure Advantage®

1986

Location

SmartDollar

Franklin, TN

My Secure Advantage®

Roseville, CA

Employees

SmartDollar

1,014

My Secure Advantage®

100

Funding Summary

SmartDollar

None

My Secure Advantage®

None

Website

Reviews

SmartDollar

4.5 (156)

Star Featured Review

Casey Basaker, SHRM-CP, MBA

October 20, 2025
SmartDollar has been very helpful and their customer service is amazing. I would definitely recommend them as an additional benefit.
Star Featured Review

Jen Schulz

October 20, 2025
Smart Dollar has been a fantastic addition to our benefit offerings. It’s such a desperately needed resource that people don’t... More
Show All Reviews

My Secure Advantage®

4.0 (6)

×
?

Need Help Choosing?

Our specialists can help prioritize the criteria that matters most and narrow the field.
Setup a Free Consult

×