Receiving a cancer diagnosis is a moment that can turn a person’s world upside down, evoking fear and devastation. Uncertainty looms as patients grapple with questions about the efficacy of treatments and the extent of the challenges that lie ahead.
The side effects of cancer treatment are infamous for their harshness, with a dauntingly long list that includes nausea, hair loss, potential fertility loss, and relentless fatigue.
However, another heavy burden is often underestimated and equally threatening – the financial toll exacted by this battle, known as “financial toxicity.”
Imagine if, on top of enduring the terrible side effects, there is a big possibility that this diagnosis could also bankrupt you.
Unfortunately, this is a reality for many, as financial toxicity paints a picture of mounting out-of-pocket costs, job loss, and escalating insurance deductibles or copayments in healthcare.
This article explores the financial toxicity that accompanies a breast cancer diagnosis and examines how employers can ensure that all workers have access to the care they need without facing financial ruin.
What is Financial Toxicity?
Financial toxicity is a growing problem that lacks widespread recognition and discussion.
One contributing factor to this lack of awareness is the relatively recent introduction of the term “financial toxicity” into the medical vocabulary, which only occurred in 2011.
So, what is financial toxicity?
Simply put, financial toxicity is a term used to describe the harmful financial consequences of a medical treatment. Think of it as the unintended, yet very real, financial strain that cancer patients experience while undergoing treatment.
Clearly, financial toxicity caused by this disease can significantly impact behavioral and mental health, leading to stress, anxiety, depression, and bankruptcy. It can also force patients to make difficult choices, such as skipping appointments, delaying treatment, or taking on unmanageable debt.
Awareness of this burden is becoming increasingly important as cancer care costs continue to rise, and many patients struggle to afford the treatment they need. One initiative aiming to raise awareness of financial toxicity and breast cancer is the Emotional Well-being and Economic Burden Research Network (EMOT-ECON), which is a collaborative effort to advance research and generate new knowledge about this pressing topic.
What is Financial Toxicity in Cancer Patients?
When discussing financial toxicity, it’s essential to understand that it represents a complex and multi-layered challenge for cancer patients. That’s because it involves both the objective or actual burden on their finances and the subjective or psychological distress they feel due to the costs associated with their treatment.
The objective financial burden includes the direct and indirect costs of care not reimbursed by health insurance:
- Direct costs include co-pays, deductibles, and other out-of-pocket expenses such as travel to and from treatment centers, childcare services, and other costs not fully reimbursed by insurance.
- Indirect costs of care include the opportunity cost of medical treatment, such as the cost of not being able to engage in meaningful employment, lost wages, and informal caregiver costs not reimbursed by insurers.
On the other hand, subjective financial distress refers to the emotional and psychological impact of financial toxicity. This can include anxiety and stress about the ability to afford care and the impact on one’s savings and future financial goals.
While it’s true that financial wellness is a concern for all cancer patients, those battling breast cancer are even more vulnerable.
What Percentage of Breast Cancer Patients Experience Financial Toxicity?
Breast cancer is the second most prevalent cancer among women in the United States, constituting approximately 30% (or one in three) of all new female cancer cases annually.
With an average lifetime risk of around 13%, meaning a one in eight chance of development in a woman’s lifetime, the statistics underline this disease’s considerable impact on society.
Given this high prevalence, a question arises: to what extent do breast cancer patients struggle with financial toxicity while battling this illness?
In high-income countries such as the United States, approximately 35.5% of breast cancer patients experience financial toxicity, highlighting the economic burden of this disease.
However, this burden amplifies dramatically in low to middle-income countries, with a staggering 78.8% of breast cancer patients facing financial toxicity.
To put this into perspective, the financial toxicity rates in these countries exceed those for various health conditions combined, which typically range from 6% to 12%.
Furthermore, a 2020 study of women with breast cancer revealed that most women had to dip into their finances to cover out-of-pocket expenses. Additionally, one in four had to borrow from family or friends, leave some medical bills unpaid, accumulate credit card debt, or defer other bill payments.
This raises another crucial question: what factors contribute to this financial toxicity among breast cancer patients?
Determinants of Financial Toxicity in Relation to Breast Cancer
Women diagnosed with breast cancer face a disproportionately high risk of encountering financial toxicity because of a mix of factors that amplify the economic burden.
Some of these factors include the exorbitant cost of breast cancer treatment, the long duration of treatment regimens, and the alarming prevalence of job loss among breast cancer survivors.
Shockingly, breast cancer has the highest treatment cost among all cancer types, accounting for 14% of all cancer treatment costs.
An in-depth assessment of direct medical costs to treat breast cancer in the United States has revealed that these expenses can escalate to a staggering $100,000 per patient over their lifetime.
What’s more, recent studies have shown that for younger and midlife women grappling with metastatic breast cancer, the cumulative financial burden can soar to over $200,000.
Even more concerning is that cases have been reported where the total cost of breast cancer care surged to an astounding $334,000, as seen in a Forbes report from 2022.
Contributing to these costs is the fact that women may have to exhaust funds for fertility preservation and egg freezing, as the side effects of chemotherapy and radiation may cause temporary or permanent infertility and menopause.
Moreover, breast reconstruction may require multiple surgeries, and some therapies for metastatic disease can cost over $18,000 per month.
It’s also worth noting that breast cancer treatment typically encompasses a year of intensive therapy and sometimes extends to five to ten years involving maintenance therapy. For those dealing with stage IV metastatic breast cancer, treatment is continuous and ongoing.
The long, natural trajectory of breast cancer treatment exposes patients to the risk of experiencing financial toxicity throughout their journey with the disease.
Risk Factors for Financial Toxicity in Breast Cancer
Breast cancer can have a significant financial impact on women, especially those who are younger, have lower incomes, or are from minority groups.
According to an overwhelming majority of studies, risk factors for financial toxicity in cancer patients include:
- Age: Due to breast cancer treatment, younger women are more likely to experience negative career consequences, such as job loss or reduced income.
- Race or ethnicity: Minority women are likelier to have lower incomes and less health insurance coverage, making them more vulnerable to financial toxicity.
- Income: Women with lower incomes are more likely to have difficulty affording out-of-pocket costs for cancer treatment, such as copayments, deductibles, and prescription drugs.
- Insurance status: Women without employment-based health insurance, cancer insurance, or inadequate health insurance coverage are more likely to experience financial toxicity.
- Employment status: Women who are unemployed or underemployed are more likely to experience financial toxicity due to lost income and health insurance coverage.
- Caregiving responsibilities: Women who are caregivers for others may have difficulty balancing their work and caregiving responsibilities, which can lead to job loss or reduced income.
The Harsh Consequences of Financial Toxicity
The staggering financial burdens have led to an alarming trend where women facing a breast cancer diagnosis are increasingly forced to make agonizing choices that can impact their health and wellness.
The long list of expenses involving diagnostic tests, surgical procedures, genetic testing, radiation therapy, systemic treatments, and even participation in clinical trials can weigh heavily on their decision-making process.
Many opt to delay crucial steps in their healthcare journey, such as screening mammography and treatment initiation, because of the financial distress accompanying their diagnosis.
A recent study found that over 30% of patients with breast cancer gave up medical care because of cost, including missing appointments (14.7%), delaying or forgoing treatment (11.9%), and taking less medication than prescribed (6.2%).
However, the consequences of these decisions can be devastating.
When women are forced to delay or forgo crucial steps in their breast cancer care due to financial distress, they are more likely to experience worse outcomes, including a higher mortality risk.
The Role of the Employer
Cancer often impedes a patient’s ability to work, support themselves and their families, maintain healthcare insurance, and afford treatment.
Breast cancer, in particular, significantly impacts work capabilities and career decisions. Several studies have shown that women with breast cancer are more likely to leave the workforce and may experience difficulty returning to work after treatment.
For example, a recent survey found that:
- 40.4% of women said their job performance had suffered
- 12.2% of women quit their jobs
- 7.5% of women lost their jobs
- 23.5% of women avoided changing jobs to keep their health insurance
- 55% of women took paid time off during treatment
- 47.3% of women took unpaid time off during treatment
Employers can play a pivotal role in helping breast cancer patients return to work successfully. Women with accommodating employers are more than twice as likely to retain their jobs than those without.
However, low-income women are less likely to have accommodating employers, making it more challenging to retain their employment status. Improving consistency in providing accommodations, regardless of job pay scales, could help narrow the employment disparities faced by women diagnosed with breast cancer.
In addition, breast cancer survivors who felt discriminated against by their employers were less likely to return to work. This suggests that employers must be aware of the potential for discrimination and take steps to prevent it.
There are a number of things that can be done to help women with breast cancer maintain their careers and create a more supportive workplace. These include:
- Providing flexible work arrangements, such as part-time work, telecommuting, or compressed workweeks.
- Offering accommodations, such as modified job duties, breaks for medical appointments, or a private space to rest.
- Educating employees about the impact of breast cancer and how to support their colleagues affected by the disease.
- Creating a supportive company culture where employees feel comfortable talking about their cancer diagnosis and asking for help.
Cancer Diagnostic & Support Services
Browse and compare 1000’s of vetted vendors.
Resources, Strategies & Support for Employees with Breast Cancer
Employers can be crucial in providing support, resources, and assistance to their employees facing chronic illnesses like breast cancer.
On top of providing flexible work arrangements and raising awareness about cancer, here are some critical programs and benefits to consider:
1. Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs)
Many employers offer EAPs, which are confidential support services that can provide counseling, financial advice, and resources to employees dealing with personal challenges, including medical conditions like breast cancer. Encouraging employees to utilize EAPs can alleviate some of the emotional and financial stress they may experience.
2. Chronic Condition Programs
Employers can implement chronic condition programs tailored to the specific needs of employees with breast cancer. These programs may offer educational resources, support groups, and access to healthcare navigators who can help individuals understand their insurance coverage and available benefits.
3. Health Management Services
Employers can partner with healthcare providers to offer health management services that focus on managing the financial aspects of breast cancer treatment. These services can help patients understand medical bills, insurance claims, and available financial assistance programs.
4. Pain Management Resources
5. Financial Counseling
Employers can offer financial counseling services to employees facing substantial medical expenses. These financial counselors can work with individuals to create budgets, navigate cost-saving options, and provide guidance on managing debt related to their treatment.
Is Mitigation or Prevention Possible?
Financial toxicity is a complex issue deeply intertwined with the American healthcare system and individual circumstances, making it challenging to completely eliminate.
However, there are practical steps that can be taken to mitigate its impact and potentially prevent it in some cases:
- Insurance reforms that involve creating comprehensive plans to cover cancer-related expenses.
- Expanding Medicare and Medicaid coverage reduces the financial burden on patients.
- Employers can support employees with flexible arrangements and assistance programs.
- Financial counseling equips patients to navigate breast cancer’s financial complexities.
- Value-based pricing in healthcare links payment to treatment effectiveness.
Despite the grim outlook, relief is on the horizon with the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022—a comprehensive federal legislative initiative to tackle inflation, decrease prescription drug costs, and advance clean energy production in the United States.
The implementation of new prescription drug regulations is planned over a seven-year period, beginning in 2024. The precise effect on the financial burden for individuals battling cancer remains uncertain.
In the end, addressing the issue of financial toxicity in breast cancer is not just a matter of healthcare, but also a matter of compassion and social responsibility, as we strive to ensure that the weight of financial ruin compounds no one’s battle against breast cancer.
- Financial Toxicity Among Patients With Breast Cancer Worldwide (National Library of Medicine)
- Health and Economic Costs of Chronic Diseases (CDC)
- Health and Economic Benefits of Breast Cancer Interventions (CDC)
- Key Statistics for Breast Cancer (American Cancer Society)
- Employment trends in young women following a breast cancer diagnosis (NCBI)
- Factors Influencing Changes in Employment Among Women with Newly Diagnosed Breast Cancer (NCBI)
- Financial toxicity and the economic cost of breast cancer therapy
- Women With Breast Cancer Who Work For Accommodating Employers More Likely To Retain Jobs After Treatment (ResearchGate)
- Mitigating Financial Toxicity in Breast Cancer From Diagnosis to Treatment and Reconstruction (Science Direct)
- The Cost of Cancer: The Impact of Cancer-Related Financial Burdens on Health and Wellness Decision-Making