Workforce Technology

The Link Between HR Risk Management & Ineffective Recruitment

Explore the critical connection between HR risk management strategies and their impact on recruitment effectiveness. Learn how mitigating risks can lead to more successful hiring outcomes.
In This Post:
Expert Contributors:
Andre Oentoro

Andre Oentoro

Founder of Breadnbeyond

These past couple of years have been challenging, to say the least. Between a growing trend of resignations, employee discontent, and the post-pandemic phenomenon of quiet quitting, the workplace has significantly changed.  

The power balance shifted towards the employee, creating new opportunities and even more risks. Now, effective HR risk management is more necessary than ever. 

As an HR-specific issue, ineffective recruitment should be at the forefront of human resources management strategies. Failing to recognize it as a significant pain point can seriously threaten the prosperity of a company. In fact, the cost of a bad hire can go as high as $240,000 in expenses related to employment, retention, and pay. 

That’s a high price to pay for an avertible liability. 

Founder of Breadnbeyond Andre Oentoro describes it as a “cause-and-effect relationship.” 

Oentoro explains: “When an organization does not have good recruitment practices in place, it exposes itself to greater risk. Not only does this put the company at a competitive disadvantage, but it can also lead to compliance issues and legal problems.” 

Thus, in this Shortlister article, we explore HR risk management in depth to find its correlation with ineffective recruitment and help companies tackle this and other risk-related challenges in the workplace.

What is HR Risk Management?

As a fundamental part of every organization, the HR department has many responsibilities to ensure a solid organizational structure, one of which is handling risks. 

So, how can HR help with risk management strategy? 

Financial risk evaluation, anticipating challenges, and identifying actions to reduce their impact broadly defines risk management for businesses. However, adding human resources into this equation gives it another dimension that puts employees as the main threat. 

In that sense, HR risk management is evaluating and assessing the risk workers pose to the organization. It’s a specific responsibility that addresses threats emerging from ineffective employee lifecycle management. This includes: 

  • Talent acquisition 
  • Employee benefits  
  • Employee reimbursement 
  • Behavior supervision 
  • Behavior management 
  • Occupational health and safety 

By identifying potential workforce liabilities, HR professionals can mitigate their effect on the company. 

Consequently, they can set up individual or coordinated solutions for all employees, management levels, and leadership.

Identifying Key HR Risk Factors

HR risk management is defined as the process of identifying, assessing, and mitigating risks that are posed by employees to the organization. 

While it may sound simple, navigating the landscape of human capital risk management can seem challenging without a clear understanding of the potential pitfalls.  

So, what are the risks in the HR department? 

To shed light on this, we’ve outlined several HR risk management examples that managers should be vigilant about: 

  • Data Security 
  • Work Hours 
  • Fair Compensation 
  • Legal Compliance 
  • Thorough Hiring 
  • Employee Safety 
  • Open Communication 
  • Misconduct 
  • Discrimination 
  • Workplace Violence 
  • Data Privacy 
  • Regulatory Adherence 

In conclusion, these highlighted human resource risk examples underscore the multifaceted nature of HR risk management.

The Role of Human Resource Management in Risk Management

Primarily, the role of HR in risk management is to handle human-caused challenges in the workplace. That includes anything from employee shortages to bad hires or poor employee performance. 

But it’s also HR’s responsibility to promote positive behavior. 

Positive employee reinforcement can be an excellent preventative strategy. For example, companies can provide career improvement opportunities or reward good performance. In return, employees will be more engaged and satisfied with their jobs. 

In fact, a Harvard Business Review report on The Impact of Employee Engagement on Performance reveals that, for 72% of employees, performance recognition can significantly impact their engagement. Ultimately, for every positive deed a company does for its employees, they will most likely return the favor. 

That’s why HR has a double role in managing risk in the workplace. One is to closely follow employees’ work on all organizational levels and promptly handle potential liabilities. But, now more than ever, its role is to also encourage optimistic outcomes that will mitigate risks in the long term.

The Role of Technology in HR Risk Management

Technology, with its innovative tools and systems, has revolutionized how organizations identify, assess, and address HR-related risks.  

Advanced software and analytics, integrated into HR risk management solutions, allow companies to track employee behavior patterns, monitor compliance with regulations, and even predict potential issues.  

With sophisticated HR management systems, real-time data can be collected and analyzed, giving HR departments unparalleled insights into potential liabilities. 

There are a number of specific tools and software that can be used to identify and mitigate risks, including: 

  • HRIS (Human Resources Information Systems): HRIS platforms can be used to track employee data, such as performance reviews, disciplinary actions, and compensation. This data can be used to identify potential risks, such as employees who are at risk of turnover or who may be engaged in misconduct. 
  • Risk Management Software: There are a number of risk management software solutions that can be used to assess and mitigate risks. These solutions typically include features for identifying risks, assessing their impact, and developing plans to mitigate them. 
  • Chatbots: Chatbots can be used to automate tasks such as answering employee questions and providing HR support. This can free up HR professionals to focus on more strategic initiatives, such as risk management. 
  • Virtual Reality (VR): VR can be used to create realistic simulations of workplace scenarios. This can be used to train employees on safety procedures, identify potential risks, and assess the impact of changes to the workplace. 

Furthermore, technology-driven HR risk management training ensures that HR professionals are equipped with the necessary skills to navigate these complexities. 

This digital transformation not only streamlines risk identification and assessment but also aids in fostering transparent communication, which enhances employee engagement, reduces misunderstandings, and prevents conflicts. 

By leveraging technology’s capabilities, organizations can navigate the evolving landscape of HR risk management with greater precision, ensuring a secure and harmonious work environment.

HR Risk Management & Employees

Saying people are a risk factor applies to leadership just as much as it does to employees.  

After all, a lousy manager is a significant liability to the company’s progress. One bad employee can undoubtedly hurt a business, but a bad manager can damage the entire workflow by decreasing team motivation, productivity, and morale.  

In fact, according to an employee survey by GoodHire, eight out of ten workers would consider quitting their job because of a bad manager.  

Another study by the American Psychological Association reveals that, for 75% of employees, their boss causes the most stress at work. As a result, poor leadership and the chronic stress it creates can cost companies over $300 billion annually and 105 million lost working days. 

In contrast, a study on The Impact of Organizational Factors on Psychological Needs and Their Relations with Well-Being found that workers who feel supported by leadership tend to be happier at work. 

As the data shows, managing risk strategies should also regard leadership-caused threats to the organization. 

In that sense, the HR department is responsible for the following: 

  • Ensuring fair treatment from the management and leadership to all workers 
  • Holding managers accountable for fluctuations in work quality 
  • Facilitating manager training 
  • Regularly getting feedback from employees 
  • Making sure the managers’ values align with the company culture

Key Risk Areas for HR Managers

Changes always bring a sense of uncertainty. However, what happened in the past few years brought up unseen workplace issues for companies. 

As employee priorities shifted, they influenced the critical risk areas for HR managers. 

Health and benefits provider Mercer pinpoints five distinct categories with liabilities that human resources should keep an eye on, especially post-pandemic. 

  • Health and safety- This includes employee mental health risks, overtiredness from low work-life balance, health conditions, and work-related injuries. 
  • Accelerated digitization- This comprises challenges from skill-set gaps, outdated technology, misalignment of strategies, data privacy, and cybersecurity risks.  
  • Environment and social- This includes diversity, equity, and inclusion risks, environment and climate change, political instability and social unrest, labor and employee relations, and dangers from catastrophic personal life events. 
  • Governance and financial- This targets increasing costs of health, risk protection and well-being, pension financial risks, administration and fiduciary, legal and compliance liabilities, and challenges with benefits decision-making and accountability. 
  • Talent practices- Employee attraction, retention, engagement, lack of depth in succession bench and talent flight, etc.

Inefficient Recruitment as a Key Risk

Inefficient recruitment is a complex issue with many causes. As such, many factors can influence it, including: 

  • Ineffective recruitment sourcing strategies 
  • Lack of understanding of the process and the recruiter’s responsibilities 
  • Bad hiring managers 
  • Employee responsibilities and roles are not clearly defined 
  • Failing to recognize a poor cultural fit for the company 
  • Losing good candidates because of a lengthy process or an inadequate offer 
  • Inequality and bias in the selection process 

One or more of these points contribute to a bad hire, posing a significant risk to long-term organizational growth. 

As Breadnbeyond’s CEO, Andre Oentoro, explains:

“Ineffective recruiting can result in high turnover, which is expensive and disruptive. It can also lead to poor company culture and decreased morale among employees. All of these factors can create an environment ripe for HR risks.”
Andre Oentoro
Founder of Breadnbeyond

Examples of Risk Management in the Workplace

Risk is different for all industries, organizations, and even departments within a company. Hence, risk management in the workplace can take many forms. Ultimately, it all comes down to unique company goals and challenges, creating the need for dozens of different human resource management strategies.  

In that regard, human resource is just one of many aspects of mitigating risk. Other common examples of risk management in the workplace include: 

  • Industry-specific Strategies 

Depending on the industry, be it manufacturing, retail, or finance, the company should conduct an analysis before launching a new product or service. That helps determine if the benefits outweigh the potential risks and create a strategy around them.  

After launching the product or service, companies should also calculate the market risk or its likely value change in the future. 

  • Compliance 

This type of threat is unanimous to every organization. Unlike HR, which emphasizes employee-caused threats and solutions, compliance risk management monitors all existing organizational processes, which includes people, procedures, and technologies. 

  • Safety 

Safety risk management is crucial for locating potential hazards and controlling their effect on the organization. There are three types of risk: acceptable, tolerable, or intolerable. Using the appropriate strategy for each ensures the well-being of a business.  

These strategies include analyzing and maintaining potential safety hazards, like regularly checking technology or human errors. 

  • Cybersecurity 

With the rise of technologies and the digitalization of most business procedures, data theft has become a genuine problem. Stealing valuable assets like documents and emails can put the business at risk, making cybersecurity a crucial part of handling risk. 

  • Risk Transfer 

When employers don’t have the means to deal with a potential risk independently, they delegate this responsibility to third parties. These could include anything from outsourcing HR compliance companies to setting up cybersecurity systems. Most of the risk then falls on these third-party providers.

HR Risk Management Strategies

Much like other examples of risk management, employee-related risks require a specific approach. HR risk management strategies are a structured way of addressing such threats. 

There could be as many different techniques as there are risks.  

But, to simplify the process, human resource specialists can set up and follow an HR risk management plan. Usually, it consists of cyclical measures that aim to identify, assess, manage, and monitor the risks and their effects.

HR Risk Management Plan

Making a plan is a central element of the risk management process. It helps HR document the whole process and usually consists of the following steps:

Identify

The first step in any risk management strategy should be identifying the key risks. For HR, an effective way to do this would be to perform a risk assessment audit. Doing this could expose what’s good, bad, or lacking within the organization. As a result, human resources will be able to prioritize solutions for the most harmful liabilities.

Assess

Next is evaluating the results. Many risks can surface with the HR risk assessment audit, and tackling all of them at the same time is simply unrealistic. HR needs to assess and prioritize by ranking the potential threats based on their severity and urgency. An HR risk assessment template can provide a structured framework for this evaluation process.

Manage

Once the list of priorities is complete, it’s time to focus on designing a strategy and implementing it. Some of the strategies include: 

  • Prevention by addressing liabilities before they occur 
  • Reduction or holding the losses of risks that can’t be prevented to a minimum 
  • Avoidance of actions that can potentially generate risk 
  • Recognition of risks that can be more harmful when avoided 
  • Risk transfer 

How successful this third step is depends on the quality and ability of the HR department.

Monitor

Once everything is set in place, the human resources department should monitor the developments. Since it’s a recurring process, the results are the best indicator of what works and what can be improved in the HR risk management strategy.

HR Audit & Risk Management

An HR audit reviews the organization’s policies, documentation, and procedures to identify potential liabilities. 

Seeing how fast-paced the work environment is, HR must keep up with the changes. That means performing regular audits to ensure legal compliance and alignment with the company’s objectives. 

The process focuses on HR operations like recruitment, onboarding, employee retention, payroll, compensations, performance management, etc. 

Some of the different audit types are: 

  • Compliance audit- This systematically compares HR techniques against legal and company policies 
  • HR functions audit- This evaluates the performance of practices like recruitment, onboarding, salary and compensation, employee training, etc. 
  • Culture audit- This allows the company to examine how employees adjust and comply with the company culture and vision 
  • Records audit- This includes an assessment of payroll records, their retention, and ongoing record compliances 

After determining the focus point, goals, and who will perform the audit, the next step would be gathering data. For a recruitment audit, that usually means data from the applicant tracking system (ATS) or surveys of current employees. 

Next would be to analyze the audit findings and identify the pain points. That helps HR plan better recruitment and other strategies, stay compliant, and avoid potential risks.

HR Risk Management Solutions

To go over every possible HR risk management solution would be futile since there’s no overarching approach to this matter. However, some aspects are somewhat universal for the human resources department.   

Some of these include following safety protocols or providing good employee conditions. However, HR also needs to:  

  • Stay informed and keep up with changes in compliance policies, government regulations, labor laws, workplace safety rules, industry norms, etc. This will help organizations to avoid lawsuits.  
  • Create a company culture that reinforces positive values. It’s a great way to avoid the risk of conflict in the workplace.   
  • Provide quality onboarding process and employee training, and get feedback after completion. This is helpful since it prevents poor performance due to inadequate or confusing execution.  

In essence, HR risk management solutions demand a proactive and comprehensive approach.

Recruitment Solutions

Hiring employees without a plan is a costly mistake for companies. HR should focus on the following aspects to avoid the risk of a potential bad hire. 

  • Develop a Recruitment Plan 

Establishing a recruitment and hiring plan should alleviate the risk of hiring under pressure. After all, making rush decisions can easily lead to hiring an unfit candidate.  

According to Oentoro, effective recruitment practices can help to reduce the risks associated with HR.  

“A well-run recruitment process will attract high-quality candidates who are more likely to be a good fit for the company. That’s where companies get a good reputation and positive company culture.” 

  • Keep The Recruitment Process Short 

Long recruitment is harmful to the company for several reasons. The main one is that the more a job position remains vacant, the more it costs the business.  

Moreover, candidates can lose interest resulting in missing out on qualified employees. 

In fact, recruiting statistics show that the average length of the hiring process is 36 days. At the same time, the top candidates are off the market in 10 days. 

  • Hire The Right Employee Persona 

Businesses with a well-established company culture should take into account more than the qualifications and experience of a job candidate. The person they hire should also be a cultural fit and share the values and objectives of the organization. Failing to do this could lead to undesired behavior in the workplace.  

In this case, it’s always good to include more people in the hiring process, like a manager or a team leader. That way, they can identify possible warning signs that others might overlook. 

  • Test For Skills 

It’s common for an employee to exaggerate their experience or skill proficiency. To rule out potentially underqualified candidates, HR can test for job skills in the earlier stages of recruitment.

Conclusion

Risk is as inevitable as the next big change in the workplace is.  

However, with the most recent geopolitical disruptions and record inflation, it’s safe to assume that business risk is rising. To keep it contained and predictable, the human resources department must keep pace with the changes.  

Effective recruitment is one part of the solution. 

Thus, moving forward, a significant focus for employers should be on having a sturdy recruitment strategy in place. That way, they remove the overall risks in the workplace, providing for more effective HR risk management.

Written by Shortlister Editorial Team

Senior Content Writer at Shortlister

Sources

Applicant Tracking Systems

Browse our curated list of vendors to find the best solution for your needs.

View Companies

Stay Informed

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest trends, expert tips, and workplace insights!

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter

Related Posts

Why do We Hate HR?

HR should be one of the company’s most helpful and valuable departments. However, for most employees, that is not the case.

What is Employee Turnover?

When a company has a reputation as a revolving-door employer, it becomes challenging to attract top talent, affecting the whole workforce dynamic. Thus, it is vital to understand what work turnover is, how to deal with it, and, better yet, prevent it from happening.